Blog Post

Knol: contrasting perspectives

Posted to Gurteen Knowledge-Log by David Gurteen on 24 July 2008



Knol: contrasting perspectives
WeblogGurteen Knowledge Log
Knowledge LetterAppears in the Gurteen Knowledge Letter issue: 99
Posted DateThursday 24 July 2008 20:11 GDT
Posted ByDavid Gurteen

Some perspectives on Knol. An enthusiastic one from Ron Young: KNOL - a unit of knowledge from Google and less so from Dave Snowden: The reductionist knol and The controlling knol and from Danah Boyd : knol: content w/out context, collaboration, capital, or coruscation.

My opinion: I am in the Snowden and Boyd camp. Without any robust process to ensure the accuracy of the articles - the breadth of quality will vary from extremely good to total rubbish or articles published by people in order to promote themselves or their obscure point of view. And whilst, Wikipedia articles are alive - they are always being challenged and updated, Knol articles are pretty much dead once posted.

I understand Knol is different to Wikipedia. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia whilst Knol is a library of articles but it still does not make up for the lack of screening or quality control.

Take a look at the articles on KM and draw your own conclusion. And in particular note this article - see the comment from Ron Young at the bottom and the author's reply!

If you are interested in Knowledge Management, the Knowledge Café or the role of conversation in organizational life then you my be interested in this online book I am writing on Conversational Leadership
David Gurteen

Follow me on Twitter

How to contact me

My Blog

Gurteen Knowledge Community
The Gurteen Knowledge Community
The Gurteen Knowledge Community is a global learning community of over 21,000 people in 160 countries across the world.

The community is for people who are committed to making a difference: people who wish to share and learn from each other and who strive to see the world differently, think differently and act differently.

Membership of the Gurteen Knowledge Community is free.
Knowledge Community


request help
visitor book
Thursday 30 May 2024
04:26 PM GDT